Upon closer inspection, however, the conference's fundamentalist Christian overtones become clear. According to the conference description, America's health problems are supposedly the result of Americans abandoning their "biblical bearings" and succumbing to self-indulgence.
"Our nation is obsessed with health and with fads about health and diet. One reason for this obsession is that we have lost our biblical bearings.The conference description laments that mealtime is rarely an opportunity for families -- defined as "individuals serving the Lord in a unified household bound by a common faith and purpose" -- to come together anymore.
We are awash in a culture that de-prioritizes the values of Christian family life, and we have forgotten many of the basics which result in blessing because we have ignored the Scripture as the all-sufficient foundation for faith and practice.
Consider that the Bible warns against gluttony and urges moderation and self-control, but our generation is the most overweight, the most self-indulgent, and (not surprisingly) the most cancer-prone generation in the recorded history of our nation."
Vision Forum points to several alleged culprits for the decline of food and mealtime, including "growing statist control over the food supply," "fragmentation of the family," and of course, "the mass exodus of mothers from the household to the external workforce." In other words, if the goshdern government would get off our backs and women stayed in the kitchen, our food culture would be better!
The workshop schedule is very revealing. While the workshops on nutrition, illness, and local food look innocuous enough, other workshops have a distinctly fundamentalist flavor.
- "Christian Manhood and the Seven Pillars of Exceptional Health: A Primer on How Fathers Can Demonstrate True Leadership In Shepherding Their Families To Wisely Steward Their Bodies for Maximum Kingdom Impact"
- "Watching What You Eat? You’re Not the Only One...” A Legal Perspective on the Federal, State and Local Government’s Intrusion Into What We Eat, How Much and What We Feed Our Children"
- "Can We Feed The World: A Biblical and Scientific Response to Statist, Environmentalist and Evolutionist Pessimism"
Thus, Vision Forum has managed to weave patriarchy, fear of so-called "statism", and distrust of environmentalism into a conference on food. Their distrust of environmentalism does not surprise me, given Doug Philips' hostility toward environmentalists and Earth Day. Still, it disappoints me because environmentalism, sustainability, and food are closely connected issues. A conference on food issues could have been a perfect opportunity to discuss the relevance of environmentalism on health and food.
The above workshop on "Christian manhood" was not the only patriarchal message among the workshops. Many of the workshops on hospitality, budgeting, and food preparation, were labeled "Ladies Workshops," as if only women performed these tasks. Given the Christian Patriarchy Movement's glorification of traditional gender roles, this is not surprising. (I wonder if I should tell them that I learned cooking from my father...)
To celebrate hospitality, "The Reformation of Food & the Family" will hold a ladies' tea hosted by Michelle Duggar and Beall Philips at the Menger Hotel. The ladies' tea will have an early 1900s theme, not unlike the Vision Forum's Titatic anniversary celebration, suggesting a longing for an earlier, more conservative era.
In short, "The Reformation of Food & the Family" discusses food issues in a decidedly right-wing, Christian Patriarchy context. To be fair, some of the concerns of the conference are valid. For instance, the conference description is critical of processed food and steroid-laden meat, which should be of serious concern to all people who take their health seriously. "The domination of pre-processed, steroid-rich, genetically manipulated food in our diet is a reflection of the priorities of modernity — live, eat, and die fast, and don’t think too much about what you are doing," the Vision Forum website says. Additionally, mealtime does offer an opportunity for families to bond, which we should remember. Unfortunately, the positive messages of "The Reformation of Food & the Family" are entwined with negative messages that encourage patriarchy, distrust of government, and neglect of environmentalism's contributions to food issues.
No kidding. And here I thought it was all because of processed foods and portion sizes!
ReplyDeleteDonna -- With fundies, everything is about the Bible, even obesity, apparently.
DeleteDid they also lament the nanny state which is so prevalent today with the right in their claim that the govt is "interfering" in their "right" to make their own food choices? This seems to go hand in hand with these distortions.
ReplyDeleteSherry -- I didn't see the exact term "nanny state," but the notion of "statism" seems to refer to that. I've heard the term "statism" used by different groups on the Right, which seems to mean government input that they don't happen to like.
DeleteI think my other comment was ignored. These verifications are awful and make it hard to leave comments ahab. They distort the letters so bad, you often can't tell what they are and then it leaves a blank comment box as if you didn't say anything. Sorry, but bloggers obsession with verifying "humans" is annoying. I never get bots on wordpress, and we don't have to bother with that stuff. Okay, I'm off the soap box.
ReplyDeleteSherry -- It wasn't ignored, it just went into the moderation queue.
DeleteI don't think the rejection of statism is particularly Christian or not Christian, and should certainly not need to be in quotes, as though you suspect it doesn't exist.
ReplyDeleteThere is ample evidence from various sources that government distortions of farming practices are much to be blamed for, among other things, the dominance of big Ag, the move towards a monoculture food supply, and the excessive burdening of small farms with requirements that fit the big playerss just fine, but not the little ones. Two recent authors that come to mind are Michael Pollan in the Omnivore's Dilemma and In Defense of Food and Joel Salatin's Everything I Want to do is Illegal or Folks, This Ain't Normal (pardon any errors in the titles - I am writing from memory).
Anonymous -- I may have given the wrong impression. I believe wholeheartedly that we should encourage our government to pass sound policies regarding food and public health. We should hold it accountable for its policies, and speak up when those policies are biased toward big agro-business. My concern with the word "statism" is that it seems to be a right-wing buzzword.
DeleteI agree with Ahab that this is too often a buzzword.
DeleteBut more fundamentally, some "traditional" practices probably SHOULD be illegal or regulated even if a regulation affects a Mexican street vendor (for example) more than McDonalds. The photographs I have seen...eek. Unrefrigerated mayonnaise, meat cooked in backyards over barely cleaned trash barrels, fruit stored in bins with no coverings. No refrigeration.