Friday, May 10, 2013

The 2013 CHAP Convention and the Christian Homeschool Movement

With the debut of Homeschoolers Anonymous and Homeschooling's Invisible Children, as well as recent attention that blogs such as Love, Joy, Feminism and No Longer Quivering have given to homeschooling, a post on a Christian homeschooling convention seemed timely. The Christian Homeschool Association of Pennsylvania (CHAP) is holding its annual conference on May 10-11 at the Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex in Harrisburg, PA. I infiltrated the CHAP convention for Republic of Gilead in 2011 and found that patriarchy, distrust of "the world", and a burning drive to keep children in the Christian fold were prominent themes.*

The annual CHAP convention is geared toward Christian homeschooling parents with a decidedly conservative worldview. Answers in Genesis founder Ken Ham and Vision Forum founder Doug Philips spoke in 2011, and other past speakers delivered talks on creationism, purity culture, and homeschool legislation.

CHAP encourages parents to bring their teenage children, having creating a teen track geared toward young people. "We applaud parents who are striving to give their children a vision of being adults rather than the cultural norm of prolonged irresponsibility," the website states, a common stereotype that fundamentalist homeschoolers have about mainstream culture.

This year's schedule includes workshops on the alleged errors of skeptics, male "headship", purity, and generational continuity.

- The Walls of Jericho: The Skeptics Come Tumblin' Down

- Keeping Your Kids Pure in Mind and Body

- Dating or Courtship: Choose God's Best!

- Teaching Your Children With Your Grandchildren in Mind

- Boys to Men: Growing our boys to be leaders in the home

- Follow Jesus and Lead Your Family: How to be the Spiritual Leader God Wants You to be

CHAP, however, is about more that education and home life. A workshop by Mike Donnelly entitled "International Homeschooling: Why Should American Homeschoolers Care what Happens over There?" suggests that the Christian homeschool movement is paying attention to the global scene. Mike Donnelly is director of international relations for the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA), a Christian homeschooling organization with its own political action committee. HSLDA's international page suggests that the global homeschooling movement is clearly on its radar.

Fundamentalist homeschoolers in many ways the Religious Right's vanguard. The messages that fundamentalist homeschoolers instill in children -- problematic messages about sexuality, stereotypical gender roles, pseudoscience, ugly caricatures of the outside world -- say volumes about their vision for future generations. If what we teach children reflects our values, then the values of fundamentalist homeschoolers are very retrograde.

While I have faith that many homeschooled youth will question the messages of their upbringing upon exposure to real life, the fact remains that their parents still embrace these values. Those parents vote. Those parents lobby. And, if Donnelly's workshop is any indication, those parents and their support organizations network globally. If we are concerned about the Religious Right, we must pay attention to the Christian homeschool movement.

For more information about CHAP, click here.  



* I intended to infiltrate this year's CHAP convention, until an unfortunate accident occurred. A tanker truck fire damaged an exit ramp off of I-81, and parts of the highway have been shut down for repairs. (No fatalities, thank goodness.) My usual routes to the Farm Show complex are inaccessible, and nearby roads are congested from diverted traffic. To reach the Farm Show Complex, I'd need to drive through parts of Harrisburg I'd rather avoid, so I decided to scrap my CHAP plans this year.

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Commentary Tidbits

Right Wing Watch: The Myth of American Christians as Persecuted Minority, part 256

GLAAD: Peter Sprigg Claims Christians Are 'Hated Minority' and CNN Lets Him Get Away with It

Box Turtle Bulletin: Joe Dallas Splits from Exodus International

Huffington Post: My Wife Is Not a Rotisserie Chicken or Leaky Faucet

Gay Star News: Christian right is losing on marriage but taking the gay hate battle to Africa

Elizabeth Esther: The New Misogyny: “bro-culture” pastors, sexist Christian comedians and abuse apologetics disguised as female empowerment

No Longer Quivering: Silencing Techniques

News Tidbits

The Tennessean: 'Christianity not for sissies,' evangelist Angus Buchan says at Mighty Men Conference in Murfreesboro

Christian Science Monitor: Elizabeth Smart speaks on human trafficking

Air Force Times: Freedom of Religion Vs. Freedom from Religion in the Military

Huffington Post: Rick Santorum Praises NRA as Constitution "Warriors"

News One: Lesbian Couple Told To Divorce Or Son Will Be Removed From Christian School

Edge Boston: Josh Ritter Protests Messiah College’s Gay Policy

The Advocate: Catholic Leaders Denounce Rhode Island Marriage Equality Law

Pink News: Rhode Island Bishop warns Catholics against attending gay weddings because it may ‘harm their relationship with God’

Pink News: Supporters of ‘gay cure’ therapy call for new hearing on New Jersey bill to ban it

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Kidnapping Survivor Elizabeth Smart on Sexual "Purity" Messages

On May 1st and 2nd, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, the Advisory Council on Child Trafficking (ACCT) and Goldman Sachs 10,000 Women hosted a symposium on child sex trafficking in Baltimore, Maryland. According to the Johns Hopkins website, the symposium was part of a White House initiative to bring together stakeholders to address the needs of sexually exploited children.

Speakers at the conference included academic, political, and social justice leaders. Among those on the agenda were U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley, Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, White House Council on Women and Girls chair Valerie Jarrett, and gender-based violence researcher Rebecca Campbell.

One of the most celebrated speakers at the event was Elizabeth Smart, abduction survivor and president of the Elizabeth Smart Foundation. At age 14, Smart was abducted from her home and sexually assaulted by Brian David Mitchell. She would spend the next nine months as his captive until she was discovered in Sandy, Utah in March 2003. According to Deseret News, Mitchell was sentenced to life in prison in 2011.

At the 9:40 mark of a Fox 13 NOW video, Smart discussed how abstinence-only efforts harm sexual assault victims and contributed to her captivity. Smart recalled a school teacher who promoted abstinence by comparing people who have premarital sex to chewed-up gum.
"I remember in school one time, I had a teacher who was talking about ... abstinence, and she said, 'Imagine you're a stick of gum, and when you engage in sex, that's like getting chewed, and then if you do that lots of time, you're going to become an old piece of gum, and who's going to want you after that? Well that's terrible! Nobody should every say that. But for me, I thought, 'Oh, my gosh, I'm that chewed up piece of gum. Nobody re-chews a piece of gum. You throw it away.' And that's how easy it is to feel like you know longer have worth, you know longer have value. Why would it even be worth screaming out? Why would it even make a difference if you are rescued? Your life still has no value."
Smart urged listeners to educate young people that "you will always have value and nothing can change that."

My heart broke for Elizabeth Smart as I listened to the video. To endure abduction and brutal violence would be traumatizing enough, but to also wrestle with dehumanizing, victim-blaming "purity" would be heartbreaking.

Sadly, none of this is new for the abstinence and sexual "purity" movement. I recall the troubling messages at a Silver Ring Thing presentation I observed in 2011. The messages that associated premarital sex with emotional and spiritual devastation were bad enough, but the messages on sexual violence made me uncomfortable. One of the speakers, a sexual assault survivor, assured listeners that they can always "start over" no matter what they've done or what's been done to them. A sexual assault victim hasn't done anything wrong or violated an abstinence vow, so what would they need to "start over" from?

These messages have been circulating for some time. Many abstinence-only programs associate premarital sex with shame and disgust, which is problematic in and of itself. However, not only is such an approach completely inadequate for discussing sexual victimization, but it can potentially foster victim-blaming attitudes.

After hearing Elizabeth Smart's heartbreaking story, can we please dispense with toxic ideas about abstinence and "purity"? Sex, whether consensual or forced, does not contaminate a person or render them "chewed-up". Human beings have intrinsic value, and an individual's worth extends far beyond their sexual experiences.

Can we dispense with the victim-blaming?

Can we dispense with antiquated ideas about sex as dirty and shameful?

Can we encourage young people to delay sex without resorting to shame, guilt, and scare tactics?

Can we embrace an ethic of sex that celebrates healthy sexuality AND recognizes and validates the experiences of sexual assault victims?

Abstinence-only "purity" messages are problematic for many reasons, but they are also harmful to sexual assault victims, as Elizabeth Smart's talk demonstrates. Let's move past one-dimensional "purity" toward a multifaceted, compassionate view of sexuality.



To read additional commentary, visit the following links.

Think Progress: Elizabeth Smart: Abstinence Education Teaches Rape Victims They’re Worthless, Dirty, And Filthy

Religion Dispatches: Traditional Mormon Sexual Purity Lesson Contributed to Captivity, Elizabeth Smart Tells University Audience

Love, Joy, Feminism: Sex and Chewing Gum: The Danger of Purity Culture

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

An Oasis of Sanity: The 2013 NFPRHA Conference


Lady Justice statute outside of
Albert V. Bryan Courthouse in Alexandria

With all the anti-choice events and rhetoric I report on for Republic of Gilead, it's refreshing when I can spend time around people who support reproductive justice. Before I share more about the Hilltop Conference, I'd like to highlight a conference of a different kind that took place this week. The 2013 National Conference of the National Family Planning and Reproductive Health Association (NFPRHA) conference took place on April 28th to May 1st at the Westin Alexandria in Alexandria, Virginia. I had the pleasure of manning an exhibit table for my workplace at the conference, where I met some amazing people who champion reproductive rights.

NFPRHA, based in Washington D.C., provides advocacy and education to professionals who work in the reproductive health care field. According to its website, "NFPRHA members have shared a commitment to providing high-quality, federally funded family planning care - making them a critical component of the nation's public health safety net." The organization advocates for publicly-funded family planning programs, insurance coverage of contraception, access to abortion, and comprehensive sex education, among other issues.


Safe sex educator kit
at one of the exhibit tables

The 2013 NFPRHA National Conference featured dozens of exhibitors from the reproductive health field, including reproductive health care providers such as Planned Parenthood, safe sex initiatives such as Bedsider, pharmaceutical companies, and anti-violence organizations. The workshop schedule featured talks on practical concerns such as funding, billing, and and coordinated care, as well as dynamic advocacy for reproductive justice. Workshops such as "Legal Attacks on Contraceptive Coverage" and "The Power of Strategic Communication to Shape Conversations on Family Planning" confronted right-wing attacks on reproductive rights and highlighted ways that activists are striving for social justice. Other workshops such as "Serving LGBTQ Patients in the Family Planning Setting" drew attention to a previously neglected population.

Most of my time was spent manning an exhibit table, but I did have the opportunity to attend "The Power of Strategic Communication to Shape Conversations on Family Planning". The panel discussion featured RH Reality Check editor-in-chief Jodi Jacobson, National Women's Law Center director of outreach Thao Nguyen, and Momentum Analysis founder Margie Omero.

Jacobson, a long-time observer of right-wing attacks on reproductive rights at RH Reality Check, argued that the right-wing has undertaken a "systemic effort" to undermine public support for basic health care. The American right-wing has created an extensive network of messages that promote discrimination and misinformation, such as rape myths and victim blaming attitudes. Jacobson delved into how anti-woman rhetoric, as part of a larger war on women, shaped the 2012 presidential election. She showed a video compilation by Think Progress of egregious right-wing comments about women, including Rick Santorum's comments about women in combat, Rush Limbaugh calling Sandra Fluke a "slut", and Fox News commentator Liz Trotta's dismissive comments on sexual assault in the military.

Jacobson complained that the mainstream news media has blurred news, opinion, and feelings, lamenting that people who come to the media with facts are labeled as advocates and seen as less credible. Convincing the media to report facts is becoming increasingly difficult, but it remains an important task.

Many people receive their news from social media, Jacobson reminded the audience, and thus social media can serve as a vital tool for disseminating information, initiating action, and prompting a rapid response. As an example of the power of social media, she cited campaigns against bills in several states mandating transvaginal ultrasounds before abortions.

Everyday people are not as immersed in reproductive justice issues as professionals and activists in the reproductive health field, she observed, and so informing them and "fighting the national narrative" is key. The majority of Americans are pro-health care and pro-decision making, making them a force that reproductive health advocates must tap into. Most people care about doing the right thing, and thus advocates should use social media to reach people where they are, Jacobson concluded.

Thao Nguyen explored the role of social media in depth with her discussion of the This Is Personal campaign, launched in late 2012 as the presidential election approached. This Is Personal was aimed at a millennial audience (ages 18-35) with no prior involvement in the reproductive health movement. Nguyen showed a video from the project, in which people read egregious quotes from public figures on sexual assault, birth control, and women's health, followed by snarky jabs. Without using the word "vote" or supporting a particular candidate, the video encouraged viewers to use their voices to protect their reproductive rights.



Nguyen discussed some of the strategies that contributed to This Is Personal's success, such as strong interaction with the target audience, correct tone, and a steady stream of fresh content. The campaign was a resounding success, she reported, adding that their audience had no "intensity gap" for the issue. When their audience was given information about reproductive rights, they responded passionately, she revealed.

Finally, Omero discussed how female voters and women's reproductive health issues shaped the 2012 election. 2012 was the first election since 1996 in which a candidate won by securing women's votes and losing men's votes, she asserted. The gender gap among those who voted for President Obama was wider in 2012 than in 2008, she added. Was this gap attributable to the war on women? Omero's answer was complex.

Focus groups with mothers revealed that few had ever heard of the war on women, and abortion was not one of the top issues motivating their vote. However, a candidate's stance on issues such as abortion served as a cue to whether or not these voters felt that a candidate truly understood them. "Does either party understand me?" is the chief question in voters' minds, Omero argued, and voters will evaluate campaigns on whether or not they believe a candidate understands their situation.

Reproductive health issues did play a role in the 2012 election. The majority of voters are pro-choice, Omero observed, and women's health and health care coverage are not only important issues, but also serve as cues as to whether voters feel a candidate understands them. This sheds light not only on President Obama's 2012 victory, but on how reproductive health matters impact politics.

In conclusion, the NFPRHA conference was both eye-opening and invigorating. Right-wing attacks on abortion, emergency contraception, public funding for family planning clinics, and insurance coverage for contraception are all too real. Fortunately, there are also progressive voices calling for rights, health, and facts. As anti-choice forced try to undermine reproductive rights for women and men, reproductive justice groups such as NFPRHA are defending those rights. As much as the far right tries to take reproductive choices away from citizens, a well-organized and devoted movement of reproductive rights activists continues to resist them. After wading through the insanity of Religious Right attacks on choice, it was rejuvenating to be among unabashedly sane people.


*   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *


I explored Alexandria in my free time, finding it to be clean, sterling, and full of surprises. The Westin Alexandria was located across the street from the Albert V. Bryan Courthouse, where a statue of Lady Justice hovered over the entrance. Justice Delayed, Justice Denied read the inscription, a perfect reminder to those attending a reproductive health conference. Green parks and ponds waited around corners, and an unexpected trellis covered in flowers captivated me.

That charm was exemplified by King Street, Alexandria's main street stretching the width of the city. Lined with restaurants, gourmet shops, bookstores, and boutiques, King Street was worth the walk. I sampled exotic olive oils and salts at Olio Tasting Room, eyed the Ganesha and bodhisattva statutes at an ethnic Tibetan store, admired tea decanters at a Moroccan shop, and picked up some used books at an inviting bookstore.

Freakin' ostrich eggs
For lunch one afternoon, I swung by Whole Foods, taking in the produce, beers, wines, and spices it sold. A basket of ostrich eggs for sale caught my eye, and I was so stunned that I took a photo. They're the size of #@%$ pummelos! I thought, disappointed that I had no means of cooking one during my stay.

In short, Alexandria (particularly King Street) is a great tourist destination for those visiting the Washington D.C. region. NFPRHA chose a great city in which to host its conference.

Commentary Tidbits

The Bilerico Project: IFI's Bigoted New Video Shows How Little They Get It

Wonkette: Here is Rick Santorum spreading leadership to high schoolers in totally non-political way

Think Progress: Former Ex-Gay Spokesperson Formally Apologizes For Promoting The Harmful Therapy

Los Angeles Times: Jason Collins and Tim Tebow: Lessons In Being True to Yourself

Truth Wins Out: Bully-Promoting Focus on the Family Complains About Mean Gays On Facebook

Right Wing Watch: Pat Buchanan Calls for 'Moratorium on Immigration from the Islamic World'

News Tidbits

Huffington Post: Mark Driscoll, Megachurch Leader, Says Nagging Wives Like Water Torture

Sacramento Bee: Christ for All Nations Announces First-Ever U.S. "Good News" Crusades

Talking Points Memo: Rick Santorum to Address NRA's Annual Meeting

NBC 4 Washington: Sentencing of Family Research Council Shooter Moved to July

San Diego Gay and Lesbian News: Anti-Gay Pastor Greg Laurie Picked to Helm Day of Prayer Events at Pentagon, Capitol Hill

Pink News: Caribbean Anglican bishops warn against equal marriage and ‘redefining’ human sexuality

Pink News: Bill to ban ‘ex-gay’ therapy to be introduced in New York